Cusimano’s Pizzeria

About

Pizza

  • star
    Yelp rating
    4.5 stars

Location

Adress: 11360 Maple Ridge Rd, Medina, NY 14103

Phone: (585) 798-6288

Work Hours

Mon 10:00 am-10:00 pm
Tue 10:00 am-10:00 pm
Wed 10:00 am-10:00 pm
Thu 10:00 am-10:00 pm
Fri 10:00 am-10:00 pm
Sat 10:00 am-10:00 pm
Sun 10:00 am-10:00 pm

Business info

  • turned_in_not
    Health Score
    70 out of 100
  • directions_car
    Delivery
    Yes
  • move_to_inbox
    Take-out
    Yes
  • credit_card
    Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • directions_bike
    Bike Parking
    Yes
  • turned_in_not
    Wheelchair Accessible
    Yes
  • local_bar
    Alcohol
    No
  • transit_enterexit
    Outdoor Seating
    No
  • wifi
    Wi-Fi
    Free
  • tv
    Has TV
    Yes
  • turned_in_not
    Waiter Service
    Yes
  • fastfood
    Caters
    Yes

Reviews

  • Kaitlin G.

    star star star star star 20 November 2026

    This is exactly the kind of pizza I like. The crust is soft yet crispy and the toppings are plentiful. The pizza sauce is very good as well. The wings are big and meaty and the sauces are amazing. The garlic Parmesan is soooo good. It has something else in the sauce and I'm pretty sure it's Italian dressing. Whatever it is, it's the best garlic Parmesan sauce I've ever had. We only have 2 options for delivery out here and Cusimano's is one of them. We are happy to pay the $6 delivery charge because they are willing to bring us food all the way in Gasport.

  • Dustin H.

    star star star star star_border 19 November 2026

    Stopped in for a quick bite on the way home after a long day.

    Great service, attentive staff. Super clean interior. I have found that with family-owned restaurants, the cleanliness can be hit-or-miss. This place has all the makings of a corporate franchise with its fancy soda machine and airy, small town decor, and I mean that in a good way.

    I bought a single slice of pizza out of the warmer because my budget couldn't afford a small pizza today. It was in a warmer, which always leaves the outside a little extra crispy and dried, but the inside was just as good as it looked. Crispy crust with a soft interior, generous toppings. I heard the veggie pizza is a favorite and I wish I'd been able to try it.

    Not quite table service, but there is indoor seating.  There is plastic tableware, parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, etc. available on a table at the front of the room. Staff seems glad to help if you need anything. A large TV hangs on the wall showing sports or something.

    If I find myself in the area again, I'll be back and I'll be ready to eat!

  • Clark S.

    star star star star star_border 8 November 2026

    I've been meaning to try Cusimano's take on the chicken finger pizza and can report that it is excellent!

    I called and ordered a medium (12", six slice) chicken finger pizza on a Saturday around 5:15pm and the kind woman on the phone said 25 minutes.  No issues picking up my pizza on time.  The staff I talked to here were incredibly nice as well!

    The pizza itself was fantastic!  Their crust is a little thicker than what you'd find in Buffalo and even more-so compared to a NY-style slice, but I tend to like a heavier crust.  The crust had a real nice taste, texture, and chew to it and was cooked perfectly, in my opinion.  The mozzarella cheese was thick and gooey and the bleu cheese sauce, which is the base sauce for this pizza, was plentiful and tasted awesome!

    Now I only have two gripes.  One being that I wish there were more chicken finger pieces spread out on the pizza itself.  They cut the pieces pretty large on top so I had to sort of hunt around for a chicken finger piece.  I think that they should use the same amount (or just a little more :) ) but cut them into smaller pieces for their medium size pizza just to ensure you get a piece in (almost) every bite.  The other issue I had was that I was never asked what type of sauce I wanted on the chicken fingers!  I've never ordered a chicken finger pizza before without being asked if I wanted hot, medium, or mild sauce.  Granted, even though the chicken fingers were plain, the pizza still tasted great, I did happen to have some Frank's and as soon as I put it on top of one of the slices, it just elevated the pizza!  Honestly, their chicken finger pizza ranks pretty high among the various places I've tried (so far), but it just seems weird to not ask about what sauce to put on the chicken fingers, which is mainly the reason why it's a four out of five star review this time.

    Cusimano's Pizzeria is a fantastic pizza though!  Their various specialty pizzas sound amazing (I definitely recommend the Cusimano specialty pizza, so good!).  Even with the little misstep, I look forward to coming back again!  I'll just have to make sure to specify a sauce on my chicken fingers when I get another chicken finger pizza from here :) .

  • Scottie S.

    star star star star star_border 7 November 2026

    Their pizza is really great. By far I believe this is my favorite pizza shop around and l think that the only reason why I can't give this a full five star review is because of regardless how good the food is all in all the last thing we needed was another pizza shop.

  • Mark D.

    star star star star star 23 October 2026

    Medina is a nice little town, and has had everything besides a decent pizza place. Luckily for us, Cusimanos has blessed us with their presence! Their pizza is delicious, and beats Avantis and Marks Pizzeria by a HUGEEE MARGIN! I say Heeuuuu-Juh!! Great pizza, delicious wings, and reasonable prices! The only reason I'd consider going to Avantis is if your wallet was uncomfortably too full with cash, and had a craving for mediocre pizza.

People Recommend